Tuesday, November 9, 2010

RIP Jeeves: Convergence Claims Latest Victim

In Memoriam
Jeeves
1996 - 2010
I'd like to begin this post by requesting a moment of silence in observation of the passing of Ask.com formerly known as AskJeeves. 

Today marks the tragic yet some would say timely passing of Ask.com, that venerable and erudite search engine that intelligently answered even the most inane and archaic of inquiries.  Jeeves came of age in the Dot.com boom. Striding with elegance and panache onto a a nubile web1.0 scene, Jeeves brought an air of much needed decorum to veritable wild wild west of talking sock puppets and Napster file sharing. Prior to the global collapse of the "old" internet Jeeves served as a sage advisor and trusted guide on the information superhighway.

This week's assignment has us exploring the concepts of "Convergence" and "Remix".  One of the definitions of convergence offered by Jenkins in "Convergence Culture" is: an old concept taking on new meanings. (p. 6)  I think the concept of the search engine fits that description quite nicely.  In the beginning the search engine was the "Oracle" one went to to research well just about anything.  Jeeves ushered in an era of digital knowledge seeking that replaced analog methods of seeking information.  Gone were the days of poring through the pages of dusty encyclopedias and paper archives. Unfortunately in the beginning the information superhighway was more often than not the misinformation superhighway. I believe first generation search engines, like Jeeves, Dogpile, et al may have undeservedly received blame when the links they served up were less accurate than they should have been. However one of the things I find most interesting is how the search engine tool itself evolved within it's own generation.

Again in the beginning the search engine was a tool to at least begin one's quest to find information. That information was often in the vein of a concept, idea, or subject to which the searcher was unfamiliar.  However it wasn't long into Jeeves tragically short life that he took on an unexpected role in addition to his info gathering duties.  Jeeves and indeed search engines in general became sort of a global phone book. As the internet evolved, died, was reborn, and evolved some more, more and more businesses co-opted the internet successfully this time to launch online storefronts.  Hence it became Jeeves' job to direct coffee drinkers to the nearest Starbucks as well as seek out information on the mating habits of wombats. Witness the convergence of old media to new media and from new media to newer media.

As in the course of any career Jeeves soon found his experience and wisdom challenged by upstart whippersnappers like Google. Next to Google's search term algorithms and clean design Sir Jeeves began to show his age.  Turns out natural language queries aren't where it's at. Why type in an entire question when one can just toss out a few key words? Suddenly the sage advisor was starting to resemble a fusty old codger.

So today we mourn the passing of a dear friend whose links and pages helped the world to transform the way it sought information.  He leaves in his wake a host of innovators and maybe a few imitators. So it's only fitting that we all take a moment to reflect on the nature of digital search while we bid a fond adieu to one of it's pioneers. Well goodbye, old chap. Say hello to Encyclopedia Britannica for me.

Note: Early reports of Bing and Google attending Jeeves' memorial solely for the purpose of gleefully dancing on his grave are completely unfounded.

4 comments:

  1. You make a clear connection of ask.com with convergence. When you say that ask.com is passing, does that mean they are taking the site down?

    ReplyDelete
  2. That's correct. It was announced a couple of weeks ago that the company was shuttering it's search engine, closing offices, and laying off engineers. Here's a couple of links:

    http://mashable.com/2010/11/09/ask-com-shut-down/

    http://thenextweb.com/us/2010/11/09/ask-jeeves-no-more-iac-shuttering-ask-com-search/

    I just entered the ask.com url and it did still serve up a search box, though suspect it is pulling results from some other search engine property, not Ask's. Thanks for your comments.

    ReplyDelete
  3. Tameka, I also find it interesting how convergence can make us question another media object's credibility. The other day I searched for something on my phone via google and in some random way I was transferred to ask.com. I didn't even continue to look for what I wanted. I settled for no information over information that I assumed to be useless, b/c a company had taken them over. Do you think this sort of questioning of something's credibility is a tool to achieve convergence or a product of successfully converging?

    ReplyDelete
  4. I loved this post! Although, I will say I think there are still people that type full questions into Google, which can be evidenced through the box that pops up as you start typing a question (some things people ask Google are hilarious).

    ReplyDelete